Stephen Sondheim‘s cherished New York City townhouse has gracefully transitioned to a new conductor, successfully hitting the market for a noteworthy $7 million. The proud new owner is a devoted Sondheim enthusiast residing in New York City, intending to transform the Midtown townhouse into their primary residence. The seven-bedroom house attracted considerable attention, receiving two compelling offers after being listed by Sondheim’s estate for $7 million in July. The Broadway maestro, celebrated for his timeless compositions, felt at home within the walls of this property for nearly six decades until his passing at the age of 91 in late 2021. Sondheim’s connection with the five-story Turtle Bay residence dates back to around 1960, following his lyrical contributions to iconic musicals like “West Side Story” in 1957 and “Gypsy” in 1959, as narrated in Pamela Hanlon’s book, “Manhattan’s Turtle Bay: Story of a Midtown Neighborhood.”

To ease the financial burden, Sondheim leased the top three floors until around 1973, a tactic detailed in the same book. Nestled in Turtle Bay Gardens, a charming ensemble of 1860s townhomes sharing a communal garden, Sondheim’s former residence has been a magnet for artistic residents over the years. Legendary actress Katharine Hepburn was a longtime neighbor, adding allure to the area. Among the unique features of the house is a music studio with a fireplace, where the maestro housed a baby grand piano. A solarium, accessible through a dramatic wooden arch, boasts original stained glass windows and a generous 30-foot terrace with a garden view. The primary suite occupies the fourth floor, while the fifth floor features a studio apartment designed for live-in staff. Celebrated for masterpieces like “Sweeney Todd” and “Into the Woods,” Sondheim’s illustrious career was adorned with an Oscar, a Pulitzer Prize, and numerous Grammy and Tony awards. It’s important to note that Sondheim also owned a residence in Roxbury, Conn., which entered the market with a listing price of $3.25 million in November. While luxury home sales in Manhattan experienced a 22.2% decline in the third quarter compared to the previous year, the median price exhibited a slight increase to $6 million, emphasizing the enduring appeal of distinctive properties, as demonstrated by the recently sold Sondheim townhouse.

Source: WSJ